Report considers impact of Immigration and Asylum Bill and earned settlement
New research by Refugee and Migrant Justice (RMJ) has found that proposed changes to the UK asylum system could have a significant impact on refugees' mental health and ability to rebuild their lives.
The 26-page report, Refugee Voices on the Immigration and Asylum Bill, can be downloaded here.
Based on interviews with 15 refugees and asylum seekers, the report considers the impact of the Government's Immigration and Asylum Bill and earned settlement reforms. Under the reforms, refugees could face a 20-year route to permanent settlement, rising to 30 years for some people who entered the UK irregularly. The new 'core protection' system for refugees introduced in March 2026 requires people granted protection from that date to renew their status every 30 months, subject to reassessment of their need for protection.
All 15 participants in RMJ's research said the reforms and proposed legislation would negatively affect their mental health.
The report notes: "The proposed 20-year route to settlement was one of the strongest concerns raised during the research. Ten of the 15 participants raised concerns about the length of the proposed route. As detailed, the government has since confirmed that refugees who entered irregularly and remain on 'Core Protection' will face an even longer 30-year route to settlement."
RMJ highlighted uncertainty over how the proposed changes would affect refugees who had already been granted protection under the previous five-year settlement route. At the time of the interviews, some participants believed they would remain eligible for settlement after five years. However, the Government's announcement on earned settlement earlier this month subsequently indicated that the extended settlement periods could also apply retrospectively to existing refugees.
Participants raised concerns that prolonged temporary status and repeated Home Office reviews would increase anxiety and make it difficult to plan for the future, establish secure homes and maintain family life.
One refugee said: "Permanent temporariness… yes, you've gained some sort of status, but because the goalposts are moving, that sort of status is temporary." Another refugee told RMJ: "How can I work in the country? How can I study to learn the language? I would have to worry every 30 months. They could decide, okay, you are not our asylum seeker, you are not our refugee. It's something that affects your mental health."
The research also highlighted concerns about proposals allowing refugees to be required to repay the cost of asylum support received while their claims were being considered. Participants questioned the fairness of repaying support they had relied upon while being unable to work.
Employment was identified as a key factor in achieving independence and integrating into communities. Participants said they wanted to use their skills, develop careers, pay taxes and support their families. All 15 participants supported giving asylum seekers the right to work while their claims are being processed.
One participant seeking asylum said: "I just want to work and pay tax and live a normal life. Doesn't the UK want that?"
RMJ emphasised that refugees and people seeking asylum were already motivated to contribute to UK society, arguing that the main barrier was a lack of opportunity rather than willingness.
While the Government says its reforms will encourage contribution, RMJ says the opposite is true as they impose more obstacles to refugees establishing themselves in the UK.
The report states: "People cannot establish economic independence while the immigration system prevents them from working. They cannot build long-term security while their immigration status remains temporary for decades on end. They cannot plan confidently for their families while their need for protection and right to belong is constantly reassessed and questioned."
RMJ makes three recommendations, calling on the Government to retain the existing five-year route to settlement, grant people seeking asylum the right to work and improve the speed and quality of Home Office decisions.