Updated guidance on detention of foreign nationals under immigration legislation
The Council of Europe's (CoE's) Committee for the Prevention of Torture (CPT) last week published updated standards setting out the human rights requirements for detaining migrants, asylum seekers and other foreign nationals under immigration legislation.
You can download the 42-page standard here.
Drawing on more than 36 years of CPT monitoring visits to CoE member states, including the UK, the standard sets out 13 areas of guidance, covering the prevention of ill-treatment, detention safeguards, accommodation, material conditions, staffing, healthcare, the treatment of vulnerable people, security measures and accountability. It also addresses the prevention of self-harm and suicide, independent monitoring, complaints procedures and contingency planning.
The CPT identifies the following guiding principles:
Immigration detention must:
- be used only as a measure of last resort;
- be non-punitive;
- be subject to accountability mechanisms.
Persons in immigration detention must:
- be protected from ill-treatment;
- be afforded fundamental safeguards;
- be held in suitable premises, with decent conditions;
- have their health needs and vulnerabilities addressed.
While the Committee acknowledges that states have the right to control their borders and determine their immigration policies, it stresses that these powers must be exercised in accordance with international human rights obligations, including the prohibition of torture and inhuman or degrading treatment and the principle of non-refoulement.
Immigration detention should be used only as a last resort, the CPT says, stressing that irregular entry for the purpose of seeking asylum is not in itself an unlawful act and does not constitute a ground for detention.
It states: "18. When a permissible ground for detention is identified following an individual assessment, authorities should first consider less intrusive alternatives to detention, particularly for persons with specific vulnerabilities. These alternative non-detention measures may include various restrictions on movement which fall short of detention, such as community supervision, regular reporting, or assignment to a specific residence.
"19. Bearing in mind that immigration detention should only be used as a measure of last resort, the detention of asylum seekers should be even more exceptional. Under international refugee law, irregular entry for the purpose of seeking international protection is not in itself an unlawful act and does not constitute a ground for detention. In those instances where there are exceptional reasons for depriving an asylum seeker of their liberty, these reasons should be fully documented. Furthermore, asylum seekers should preferably be held separately from foreign nationals who have not applied for international protection."
The CPT also calls on states to provide adequate legal and procedural safeguards, stating: "16. Procedural safeguards – such as the provision of decisions in writing and in a language and form which the persons understand, timely and effective access to legal assistance throughout the procedure, the right to be heard in person by the decision-making authority, access to interpretation, the right to receive a written, reasoned decision, the possibility to appeal, and the automatic suspensive effect of the appeal – are essential to preventing violations of Article 3. The process should ensure confidentiality, provide an objective analysis of the human rights situation in the receiving country, and include an individual assessment of the prima facie risk of ill-treatment in the event of removal of the person concerned."
On legal assistance, the standard clarifies: "25. The right of access to a lawyer applies from the outset of detention and continues throughout the entire period of deprivation of liberty. It includes assistance with matters relating to detention, residence, and removal, as well as the right to confidential communication with a lawyer and to have legal counsel present during official interviews.
"26. The right of access to a lawyer includes access to free legal aid for persons who cannot afford the services of a private lawyer. Detained persons should be informed of available providers and legal counselling schemes should be established, where possible, with in-person, telephone, or video call duty lawyer systems. Authorities should cooperate with relevant Bar Associations to effectively guarantee this right.
"27. Effective access to a lawyer also requires the removal of barriers, including disproportionate restrictions on mobile phone, telephone, and internet use. Lawyers should be enabled to consult personal files and have prompt and effective access to their clients, including any meetings required prior to judicial hearings or official interviews, with the assistance of an interpreter provided free of charge, if requested by the person or by staff. Administrative requirements should not be unnecessarily burdensome, such as unduly limiting the frequency or duration of legal consultations."
The CPT said the updated guidance is intended to help member states prevent ill-treatment and ensure that all foreign nationals deprived of their liberty are treated with dignity and held in humane conditions consistent with the administrative nature of immigration detention.
Emphasising the need for humane and decent conditions, the Committee said its visits had repeatedly identified overcrowded and unsuitable detention facilities, poor material conditions, prolonged detention and restrictive regimes.