MAC publishes major review of Global Talent and Innovator Founder routes to determine effectiveness
The Migration Advisory Committee (MAC) yesterday published its review of the UK's talent visa routes, recommending that the Government abolish the Innovator Founder visa in its current form after concluding it is not achieving its objectives.
The 80-page review can be downloaded here.
For the review, the MAC examined the Global Talent and Innovator Founder routes to determine how effective they are at attracting highly skilled, talented individuals to the UK.
"Overall, we find that the Global Talent route is largely meeting its objectives, and that the Innovator Founder route is not. We recommend small tweaks to improve the Global Talent route's effectiveness. For Innovator Founder, we recommend either abolishing the route or substantially reforming it to make it more selective," the MAC said.
The MAC said the available evidence suggested that the Innovator Founder route was not working as intended and that the proportion of low-performing businesses, even after several years of trading, alongside the low incomes of visa holders, was concerning.
Although a small proportion of businesses and visa holders appeared to perform very well, the Committee said their results did not compensate for the poor outcomes experienced by the majority. It also warned that the route could create a net fiscal cost over the long term.
The MAC acknowledged that selecting successful entrepreneurs was inherently difficult, noting that many businesses fail or remain relatively small and that it is not always possible to identify in advance which businesses will succeed.
It concluded: "We believe the performance of the Innovator Founder route is poor enough to justify abolishing it. The proportion of low performing businesses, even after several years of trading, and the low incomes of visa holders on the route are concerning. It suggests that the vast majority of visa holders are not meeting the route's objectives. The key question is whether the higher-performing parts of the route can be salvaged. A small percentage of Innovator Founder visa holders and businesses appear to perform very well, and we saw individual case studies of impressive businesses. If the most promising could be identified in advance, it would be possible to retain the route and make it much more beneficial. Endorsing Bodies told us that while some of the most successful businesses can be predicted from the initial application, many cannot."
If the Government decides to retain the route, the Committee recommended substantial reforms to make it more selective. These include extending the standard period before settlement from three to five years, allowing more time to assess business performance, and introducing more robust measures of business success.
It also recommended addressing potential conflicts of interest involving Endorsing Bodies by allowing them to provide paid-for support services only to applicants endorsed by other bodies. Interviews should be retained as part of the assessment process, while the innovation requirement should not be removed unless replaced by an equally stringent criterion.
By contrast, the MAC found that the Global Talent visa was largely functioning well, although it identified areas for improvement. It estimated that people who arrived through the Global Talent route in 2022/23 would generate a positive net fiscal impact over their lifetimes of approximately £420,000 per person, or £2.2 billion overall.
The route, which is primarily used by academics but also attracts workers in technology and the creative industries, has no salary or employment requirements. Nevertheless, the Committee found that employment rates were high and earnings respectable, with average earnings comparable to those on the Skilled Worker route when differences between industries were taken into account.
However, it raised concerns about the number of low earners on the route. It noted: "The distribution of earnings on the Global Talent route is more concentrated at the extremes, with substantial numbers of high and low earners. We find that between 8% and 21% of Global Talent main applicants granted visas in 2022/23 had earnings below the proposed Earned Settlement minimum income threshold of £12,571 in their second year. The range reflects uncertainty around those with no recorded earnings, who may not have entered or remained in the UK, or whose earnings may not be fully captured in the data. The incidence of low pay is driven partly, but not exclusively, by low-paid workers in the creative industries. One result is that the bottom two deciles of the Global Talent route are expected to be a fiscal cost over the course of their lifetimes. This is concerning for a route aimed at globally talented individuals."
To address the concerns, the MAC recommends introducing a modest income requirement for applicants seeking settlement, set at a level sufficient to support a basic standard of living and based on at least the full-time National Living Wage.
Other recommendations include requiring reference letters to be sent directly and confidentially to Endorsing Bodies, introducing guidance to prevent referees from supporting applicants where there is a conflict of interest, and requiring evidence of sustained engagement in the applicant's field of talent when applying for settlement.
Among the cross-cutting issues, the MAC considered concerns over settlement arrangements for dependants of Global Talent and Innovator Founder visa holders, who currently face a five-year pathway to settlement compared with three years for many main applicants. Stakeholders argued that the disparity could affect highly skilled migrants' decisions to move to or remain in the UK, creating additional costs and uncertainty for families where the main applicant qualifies for settlement earlier.
The Committee noted that the Government's November 2026 response to its Earned Settlement consultation had addressed concerns over a potentially wider disparity by bringing dependants' settlement pathway in line with that of main applicants and allowing couples to meet mandatory earnings requirements at household level. It said the change was sensible, given the rationale for considering household circumstances rather than treating applicants and partners separately, although a discrepancy may remain in cases where main applicants qualify after three years and dependants after five.
More generally, the MAC recommended a major review of guidance for both visa routes, after stakeholders raised concerns that information was fragmented across GOV.UK and Endorsing Body websites and unclear on eligibility criteria and the evidence required. A 2024 evaluation of the Global Talent visa found that 32% of respondents wanted more guidance on the endorsement process and 34% wanted clearer information on what applicants needed to provide. The Committee recommended reviewing Home Office and Endorsing Body guidance, including how and where it is published, and updating it annually.