Skip to main content

Report highlights cultural barriers on identity, relationships and vulnerability in immigration and asylum tribunals

Summary

Public Law Project issues its second report on cultural, procedural and linguistic barriers to access to justice

By EIN
Date of Publication:
HM Court and Tribunals logo [Source: EIN]

The Public Law Project (PLP) has this month published a second report identifying concerns about cultural understanding and procedural fairness in UK immigration and asylum tribunals.

You can download the 29-page report here. It was authored by Dr Selbi Durdiyeva and focuses on identity, relationships and vulnerability. It follows on from PLP's earlier June report on language, evidence and procedure.

The new report explains: "This report examines how applicants experience the system and whether it is possible to translate family and/or private life, LGBTQ+ identity and belonging, and mental health and trauma into 'objective' evidence, given the inherently heterogeneous ways in which people experience sexual identity, relationships and mental health. The report's central argument is that cultural understanding lies at the heart of asylum and immigration tribunals, thereby making cultural competence a procedural fairness matter."

It analyses 271 Upper Tribunal (Immigration and Asylum Chamber) decisions issued between December 2023 and December 2025. The research also draws on six hearing observations and seven interviews with legal representatives, interpreters and an intermediary.

The findings identify recurring issues in how decision-makers assess applicants' personal circumstances and credibility. In cases involving family and private life, the report found that expectations about what constitutes family relationships and the evidence needed to demonstrate them can be restrictive and influenced by Western-centric assumptions.

It highlights a tendency to apply hierarchical ideas of family life, treating some relationships as more natural or deserving of recognition than others, while overlooking the varied ways family relationships are formed and maintained. It also raises concerns that applicants can be disadvantaged by demands for documentary evidence that does not reflect how relationships are understood or recorded in their countries of origin.

Regarding LGBTQ+ asylum claims, the report highlights expectations that applicants should conform to narrow, homogenised or rigid assumptions about what it means to be LGBTQ+.

The report states: "This was evident in some First-tier Tribunal decisions, where judges treated sexuality as limited to relationships; expected a clear, cohesive, and linear account of 'coming out' as an 'emotional journey'; expected uniform openness about sexuality from the applicants; adopted a one-size-fits-all approach to evidence; and at times resorted to stereotypical language or observations. Some of the decisions demonstrated not only a lack of cultural awareness and sensitivity but also a general lack of understanding of what constitutes LGBTQ+ identity."

Regarding mental health and trauma, the research found that some decisions reflected expectations of clinical diagnoses and consistent accounts of traumatic experiences. It noted that trauma does not necessarily follow a linear pattern and that cultural differences can influence how individuals understand and discuss their mental health.

In addition, the report highlights a lack of consideration for how people in different cultures talk about mental health and trauma.

To address the failings found, the report recommends improved training and guidance for judges, the Home Office, the Ministry of Justice and other organisations involved in the tribunal system. Its recommendations include adopting more flexible approaches to evidence, improving understanding of LGBTQ+ identities, and ensuring that decision-makers consider the effects of trauma and vulnerability on applicants' ability to participate in proceedings.

It continues: "A mindset shift is also needed to recognise the importance of culturally sensitive and traumainformed approaches to evidence, credibility assessment and tribunal procedure. Greater support is needed for those involved in the process, given the highly traumatic nature of the interaction and the prevalence of trauma and vulnerability which affect applicants' capacity to recall and to engage effectively in the process. Decision-makers need to explicitly recognise and pay attention to the variety of human experiences related to family and/or private life and LGBTQ+ identity, and adopt an approach that is grounded in listening and openness to the varied ways people self-identify and relate, rather than relying on pre-made assumptions. This change in procedural culture would help reduce avoidable appeals, improve consistency, ensure fairer outcomes for applicants, and enhance confidence in the fairness and integrity of the asylum tribunal system."